If you could go back and buy your first five woodworking tools knowing what you know now, what would you pick?
I asked myself this question recently while reorganizing my shop. I was looking at tools I use every single day and tools that have been collecting dust for months. The overlap between "tools I bought first" and "tools I actually needed first" is embarrassingly small.
Here's what I'd do differently.
The Five I Wish I'd Bought First
1. A Good Combination Square
Not a speed square. Not a framing square. A 12-inch combination square with a reliable blade that actually locks.
This is the most-used tool in my shop. I reach for it dozens of times a day — checking squareness, marking lines, setting depths, verifying flatness. A good one costs $30-50. A cheap one costs $12 and lies to you about whether things are square, which is worse than not checking at all.
I started with a $9 combination square from the hardware store. It was off by about 2 degrees. I didn't realize this until I'd built three projects wondering why my joints never quite closed. Two degrees doesn't sound like much until you're trying to make a box and the lid doesn't sit flat.
Buy once: Swanson, iGaging, or if you want the gold standard, a Starrett. Your projects are only as accurate as your measuring tools.
2. A Random Orbit Sander
I spent my first two months sanding everything by hand. I thought it was "the right way" and that machine sanding was somehow cheating or inferior.
It's not. Hand sanding has its place — final passes, getting into corners, breaking edges. But for flattening surfaces, removing mill marks, and working through grits on large pieces? A random orbit sander isn't just faster. It's more consistent. The random orbit pattern prevents the directional scratches you get from hand sanding or belt sanding.
A 5-inch random orbit sander is $60-80 for a good one. It'll save you hours per project and your forearms will thank you.
My pick: The DeWalt DWE6423. Reliable, good dust collection, variable speed. Nothing fancy, just works.
3. Decent Clamps (More Than You Think)
"You can never have enough clamps" is a woodworking cliche because it's absolutely true.
I started with four clamps. Four. I tried to do a cutting board glue-up with four clamps and ended up with gaps wide enough to see daylight through. Proper clamping pressure requires clamps every 6-8 inches along a joint. A standard cutting board needs 6-8 clamps minimum. A tabletop? Twelve to sixteen.
Don't buy expensive clamps to start. The Bessey Clutch-Style clamps and Pittsburgh bar clamps from Harbor Freight are perfectly fine for most work. Buy a dozen. You'll use them all.
The ratio: Whatever number of clamps you think you need, double it. You'll use the extras within a month.
4. A Marking Knife
This one surprised me. I thought pencils were fine for marking cut lines. They're not — at least not for joinery.
A pencil line is wide. Depending on how sharp it is, that line could be 1/32" to 1/16" wide. When you're cutting to a line for a joint, that ambiguity matters. Do you cut on the left side of the line? The right side? The middle?
A marking knife scores a single, precise line into the wood fiber. Your chisel or saw registers against it perfectly. There's no ambiguity. The accuracy difference between knife lines and pencil lines in joinery work is immediately noticeable.
A basic marking knife is $15-20. It fundamentally changed the tightness of my joints.
5. A Card Scraper
The most underrated tool in woodworking. A $10 piece of flat steel that replaces 80% of your sanding in hardwood.
Card scrapers remove thin shavings — thinner than a hand plane — and leave a surface that's smoother than sandpaper. They don't clog. They don't create dust. They don't round over edges the way sandpaper does. And they're incredible for removing dried glue squeeze-out without damaging the surrounding wood.
The learning curve is in sharpening — you need to burnish a hook on the edge, which takes practice. But once you get it, you'll wonder how you ever finished a project without one.
Start here: A rectangular card scraper from Bahco. Learn to sharpen it properly (there are excellent YouTube tutorials). Your finishing game will level up overnight.
The Three I Wasted Money On
1. A Biscuit Joiner ($180)
I bought a biscuit joiner because I thought it was essential for edge-joining boards. It's not. For edge joints, a well-jointed edge and good clamp pressure is all you need — the glue joint is stronger than the wood itself.
Biscuits are alignment aids, not strength aids. And for alignment, you can use cauls or dowels for a fraction of the cost. My biscuit joiner has been used maybe five times in a year.
If you're building cabinets professionally, it has its place. For a home shop? Skip it. Put that $180 toward clamps and sandpaper.
2. A Dovetail Jig ($120)
I bought a router dovetail jig before I could cut a straight line with a hand saw. The jig sat in a box for four months while I built up basic skills. When I finally used it, the results were fine — but they looked machine-made, because they were. The charm of dovetails is that they look hand-cut.
Learn to cut dovetails by hand first. It's frustrating at the beginning but deeply satisfying once it clicks. If you later decide you want machine-cut dovetails for production work, buy the jig then. Don't start there.
3. An Expensive Router Bit Set ($200)
I bought a 35-piece router bit set because it seemed like a good deal. Thirty-five bits! I've used six of them. The straight bit, the round-over, the chamfer, the flush trim, the rabbeting bit, and the cove. That's it. The other 29 sit in a wooden case looking impressive and doing nothing.
Buy router bits individually as you need them. A good straight bit is $15. A quality round-over is $20. You'll spend $60-80 on the bits you actually use instead of $200 on a set where most of them gather dust.
The Bigger Lesson
The tools that matter most when you're starting out aren't the exciting ones. They're the boring ones — measuring, clamping, marking, sanding. The fundamentals.
Every time I rushed past the basics to buy something flashy, I regretted it. Every time I invested in a quality version of something simple, it paid off immediately and permanently.
Start with the boring stuff. Get good with it. The exciting tools will still be there when you're ready.
— Ben Caparoon
— Ben Caparoon
← All Posts