My first cutting board was made from whatever pine was on sale at Home Depot.
Don't do that.
Pine is too soft. It absorbs moisture, warps, and your knife will leave deep grooves that harbor bacteria. For a cutting board that lasts years, you need a hardwood — specifically, one with a Janka hardness rating of at least 1,000 lbf.
The Big Three
Hard Maple (Janka: 1,450 lbf)
The gold standard. Dense, tight grain, takes a beautiful finish. White color shows wear over time, which some people love and some hate. Relatively affordable compared to other hardwoods.
Black Walnut (Janka: 1,010 lbf)
Rich, dark chocolate color. Stunning as a standalone board or mixed with lighter woods. Slightly softer than maple, which some argue is kinder to knife edges. More expensive, but worth it.
American Cherry (Janka: 995 lbf)
Warm amber color that deepens beautifully over time. Slightly softer, but still plenty hard for a cutting board. Smells incredible when you're machining it.
What to Avoid
- Pine, fir, poplar: Too soft. They'll absorb moisture and split.
- Open-grain woods (oak, ash): The large pores trap bacteria. Harder to keep food-safe.
- Bamboo: Actually too hard. Will dull your knives faster.
- Anything with a finish you can't identify: If you don't know what's on the wood, don't put food on it.
The Finish Question
Mineral oil + beeswax. That's it. Don't use vegetable oil (it goes rancid), don't use Danish oil (not food-safe when wet), and don't use polyurethane (it'll peel).
Apply mineral oil, let it soak in, wipe off excess, repeat 3-4 times over a few days. Then buff in a beeswax-mineral oil paste as a topcoat. You'll need to re-oil occasionally, but it'll last for years.
Your board is going to touch someone's food. Keep it simple and safe.
— Ben Caparoon
← All Posts